My PDA case in today's Seattle Weekly
My case makes another article in the Seattle Weekly!
The latest goings-on in my long-running Public Disclosure Act case against Ron Sims and King County are the focus of yet another article in this week's Seattle Weekly. See:
http://www.seattleweekly.com/features/0531/050803_news_records.php
(Note: August 7, 2005 update to the below: as of no later than yesterday, the "on-line"version of the article has had the below item corrected. The original print version, for those who read it, contains the original error.)
There is one fact error in the article. I wasn't awarded "over $100,000" for legal expenses in 2001 at the first trial. Rather, it was approximately $89,000, versus approximately $150,000 in legal costs incurred by then. The total initial award was approximately $114,000, incuding the legal cost award plus $25,000 in penalties - resulting in the total award, with penalties, still being $36,000 short of the legal expenses alone. (Details are in the 31 page trial court's opinion, available at www.ArmenYousoufian.com )
In other words, I had supposedly won my lawsuit against Ron Sims and King County under a law that says that if I prevail, I am to be awarded my legal costs. But even after adding in $25,000 in penalties, the award was $36,000 short of the legal costs alone! The trial judge nearly cut the legal costs incurred in half! (Details of how she did that are in the 31 page opinion mentioned above.)
That bad outcome, while supposedly winning the case (who would risk pursuing a PDA violation case like mine in the future if that's the prospect of what you'd be looking forward to?), was one of several reasons I appealed the case. Not just for my own sake, but for future document requestors who would otherwise have a huge disincentive or burden against suing to get documents that were illegally withheld.
(All this assumes my legal costs incurred were reasonable, which we felt they were considering what we had to deal with in King County's conduct that had caused so much legal effort to have been expended to finally get production of documents whose very existence had been denied for four years!)
Armen Yousoufian

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home